Blog

Smoke Signals, Sanity Checks, and Regression Reflections: What They Are and When to Use Them

Emilia Krzemińska-Komenda
Emilia Krzemińska-Komenda
Quality Assurance Engineer
July 10
4 min
Table of Contents

In the constantly changing landscape of software development, ensuring the quality and reliability of your code is essential. Here is where testing comes into play, serving as a safety net that catches bugs and glitches before they reach your users. However, not all tests are created equal. This post will clarify the confusion around three frequently mixed-up tests: smoke, sanity, and regression. We’ll dive into their unique roles and discover how to use them effectively.

Smoke, Sanity, Regression: Often Confused, Rarely Understood

Even though they’re important, smoke, sanity, and regression tests are often mixed up or misunderstood, leading to their incorrect use and missed issues. The lines between these tests can blur, particularly when dealing with smaller, less complex applications. This confusion can result in wasted resources, insufficient testing coverage, and ultimately, the risk of releasing software with undetected bugs or regressions. Understanding the nuances of each test type is crucial for establishing a solid and effective testing strategy.

Smoke Tests: The Quick Health Check

The name of this test type refers to checking if a device literally “smokes” (fails) when first turned on. Imagine a smoke test as a glance at your application’s key functions. It’s a set of high-level tests designed to quickly verify that the most critical functionalities are working as expected. Think of it as a doctor checking your pulse and blood pressure. A smoke test is typically performed after a new build or deployment, acting as a gatekeeper that prevents faulty code from progressing further in the development pipeline.

  • When to use: After a new build, before major deployments, or as part of a continuous integration (CI) pipeline.
  • Purpose: To quickly detect major issues and prevent wasting time on further testing if critical functionalities are broken.

Sanity Checks: A Deeper Dive

If smoke tests are a quick pulse check, sanity checks are a more detailed examination. They are a subset of regression tests that focus on specific areas that were recently changed or fixed. Sanity checks ensure these changes haven’t unintentionally introduced new problems elsewhere in the codebase. They’re like a doctor checking that a recently treated condition hasn’t caused any unexpected side effects in other areas of your health.

  • When to use: After a bug fix, a small code change, or as part of a smoke test suite.
  • Purpose: To confirm that recent changes or fixes haven’t introduced new bugs and to avoid wasting time on extensive regression testing if there are obvious problems.

Regression Tests: The Comprehensive Checkup

Regression tests are the most extensive type of testing. They rerun a set of tests to make sure that new code changes haven’t broken existing functions. Think of it as a detailed medical checkup, where doctors re-examine various aspects of your health to ensure everything functions correctly. Regression tests provide a safety net against unintended side effects and ensure your software remains stable.

  • When to use: Before major releases, after significant code changes, or periodically as part of maintenance.
  • Purpose: To catch regressions (bugs that reappear after being fixed), ensure that new features haven’t broken existing functionality, and maintain the overall stability of the application.

Smoke, Sanity, Regression: A Testing Trinity

While each type of tests has a specific purpose, they often work together to form a complete testing strategy. A typical workflow might look like this:

#1. Smoke Test: After a new build, run a quick smoke test to check for critical issues. If it fails, the build is rejected and returned for fixing.

#2. Sanity Check: If the smoke test passes, run a sanity check to verify recent changes or fixes and ensure they haven’t introduced new problems.

#3. Regression Test: If the sanity check passes, run a full regression suite to ensure the application’s overall stability, checking that all functionalities remain intact after the recent modifications.

Smoke, Sanity, Regression: A Testing Trinity

This sequential approach provides a layered safety net, allowing for early detection and resolution of issues before they snowball into more significant problems. By systematically combining smoke, sanity, and regression testing, teams can efficiently maintain high quality and stability throughout the software development lifecycle.

Choosing the Right Test: A Balancing Act

The choice of which test to use depends on several factors, including the scope of the change, the available time, and the risk tolerance. Smoke tests are quick and essential for catching major issues early on. Sanity checks are more targeted and can be used to verify specific changes. Regression tests are the most comprehensive but also the most time-consuming. Achieving the right balance between these tests is crucial for maintaining a healthy development process.

In conclusion, smoke tests, sanity checks, and regression tests each play a crucial role in maintaining the quality and stability of software throughout its lifecycle. By understanding their specific purposes and using them strategically, development teams can optimize testing, catch issues early, and deliver reliable software that meets user expectations. Remember, effective testing is not just about finding bugs; it’s about building confidence in your code and ensuring a positive user experience.

Emilia Krzemińska-Komenda
Emilia Krzemińska-Komenda
Quality Assurance Engineer
  • follow the expert:

Testimonials

What our partners say about us

Hicron’s contributions have been vital in making our product ready for commercialization. Their commitment to excellence, innovative solutions, and flexible approach were key factors in our successful collaboration.
I wholeheartedly recommend Hicron to any organization seeking a strategic long-term partnership, reliable and skilled partner for their technological needs.

tantum sana logo transparent
Günther Kalka
Managing Director, tantum sana GmbH

After carefully evaluating suppliers, we decided to try a new approach and start working with a near-shore software house. Cooperation with Hicron Software House was something different, and it turned out to be a great success that brought added value to our company.

With HICRON’s creative ideas and fresh perspective, we reached a new level of our core platform and achieved our business goals.

Many thanks for what you did so far; we are looking forward to more in future!

hdi logo
Jan-Henrik Schulze
Head of Industrial Lines Development at HDI Group

Hicron is a partner who has provided excellent software development services. Their talented software engineers have a strong focus on collaboration and quality. They have helped us in achieving our goals across our cloud platforms at a good pace, without compromising on the quality of our services. Our partnership is professional and solution-focused!

NBS logo
Phil Scott
Director of Software Delivery at NBS

The IT system supporting the work of retail outlets is the foundation of our business. The ability to optimize and adapt it to the needs of all entities in the PSA Group is of strategic importance and we consider it a step into the future. This project is a huge challenge: not only for us in terms of organization, but also for our partners – including Hicron – in terms of adapting the system to the needs and business models of PSA. Cooperation with Hicron consultants, taking into account their competences in the field of programming and processes specific to the automotive sector, gave us many reasons to be satisfied.

 

PSA Group - Wikipedia
Peter Windhöfel
IT Director At PSA Group Germany

Get in touch

Say Hi!cron

    Message sent, thank you!
    We will reply as quickly as possible.

    By submitting this form I agree with   Privacy Policy

    This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to our Privacy Policy.

    OK, I agree